How to Qualify Shopify Leads Before Outreach [Agency Playbook]

TL;DR: Qualified Shopify leads have 5 signals: right traffic tier (10k-50k), sophisticated tech stack, active marketing, multiple contacts available, and clear pain points you can solve. Use StoreInspect to filter stores by these signals and export qualified leads with verified contacts.

---

You found 500 Shopify stores in your target niche. You scraped their emails. You wrote a killer cold email sequence.

Then you send it. And... crickets.

Here's the brutal truth: most Shopify cold outreach fails because you're emailing the wrong stores. Not wrong niche. Wrong fit. You're pitching Klaviyo migrations to stores that just launched last month. You're offering $10k website redesigns to self-funded founders making $5k/month.

The fix isn't better copy. It's better qualification.

This guide shows you exactly how to qualify Shopify leads before wasting time on bad prospects. You'll learn the 5 signals that predict whether a store will respond, a scoring framework to prioritize your list, and filtering criteria used by agencies closing $1M+ in annual services.

Why 90% of Shopify Cold Outreach Fails

Let's start with numbers that should scare you.

The average B2B cold email response rate is 4-6%. But that's the average across all outreach - including highly targeted campaigns with qualified leads.

For mass emails to random stores? Response rates drop below 1%. You send 500 emails, get 3 replies, and 2 of those are "please remove me from your list."

Why does this happen?

Qualification solves all of this before you write a single email.

The goal isn't more leads. It's better leads. 50 qualified stores will outperform 500 random ones every time.

What Makes a Shopify Lead "Qualified"?

A qualified Shopify lead is a store that:

1. Can afford your service - Has revenue and budget signals
2. Needs your service - Has a gap or pain point you solve
3. Is reachable - Has decision-maker contacts available
4. Is ready to buy - Shows growth signals and active investment

This sounds obvious. But most agencies skip this step because it takes time. They'd rather blast 1,000 emails than carefully check 100 leads. Research shows that 67% of lost sales come from not qualifying leads properly.

That's backwards. Here's why:

Same effort. 3x the deals. Qualification isn't extra work - it's the only work that matters.

The 5 Signals of a Qualified Shopify Lead

These are the 5 signals that predict whether a store will respond - and actually become a paying client.

Signal 1: Right Traffic Tier (Size)

More traffic usually means more sales. More sales means more budget for services like yours.

The sweet spot: 10k-50k monthly visitors

Why 10k-50k is ideal:

• Big enough to pay - They're making real revenue
• Small enough to care - No layers of bureaucracy
• Growth-minded - Actively investing in the business
• Decision-maker accessible - Founder still reads their email

How to check traffic tier:

Use StoreInspect to filter stores by traffic tier. Or use the free Store Inspector extension to check individual stores.

Signal 2: Advanced Apps (Tech Stack)

The apps a store uses tell you a lot about their budget. A store running Klaviyo, ReCharge, and Triple Whale is very different from one using only free apps.

What their apps tell you:

Red flags:

• Only free apps installed
• No email marketing app at all
• No analytics beyond basic Shopify
• Using Dawn theme with zero customization

The opportunity angle:

Sometimes missing apps are the signal. A store doing 30k/month traffic with NO email marketing app? That's a Klaviyo agency's dream lead. They clearly need help.

Filter by "stores NOT using Klaviyo" to find these opportunities.

Signal 3: Active Marketing Investment

Stores that spend money on marketing have budget. They understand what works. They're focused on growth. These are your best prospects.

Signals of active marketing:

The Facebook Ad Library trick:

Ads running for 30+ days are likely profitable. The store has budget AND is making it work. These are your best prospects.

Stores running multiple ads on Meta and TikTok, with Klaviyo and Triple Whale installed? They're spending $10k+/month on marketing. They can afford your services.

Signal 4: Multiple Contacts Available

One email isn't enough. Decision-makers are busy. Emails get buried. You need 2-3 contacts at every target store.

Why multiple contacts matter:

Who to target by service type:

StoreInspect includes 2-5 verified contacts per store - founders, CMOs, and ecommerce managers. So you can reach the right people, not just "info@" addresses.

Signal 5: Clear Pain Points You Can Solve

The best leads have an obvious gap between where they are and where they should be. Your job is to spot that gap before you reach out.

Pain point signals:

The "mismatch" method:

Look for stores where one area is sophisticated but another is neglected. A store with Triple Whale and ReCharge but still using Mailchimp? They clearly spend on tools - they just haven't upgraded email yet. Perfect Klaviyo pitch.

The STAMP Lead Scoring Framework

Here's a simple framework to score leads fast. Give each store a score on 5 criteria, then focus on the highest scores.

STAMP = Size, Tech, Activity, Multiple contacts, Pain

Maximum score: 100

How to use STAMP scores:

Example scoring:

Store: Premium skincare brand

• Traffic: 25k/month → 20 points
• Tech: Klaviyo, ReCharge, Judge.me → 20 points
• Activity: Meta + TikTok pixels, running ads → 20 points
• Contacts: Founder + CMO + Ecom Manager → 20 points
• Pain: Using Mailchimp, you sell Klaviyo migrations → 20 points

Total: 100/100 - Hot lead, prioritize immediately

Building Your Qualification Checklist

Turn the STAMP framework into a practical checklist for your team.

Quick Qualification Checklist

Before adding any store to your outreach list, verify:

• Traffic tier matches your ideal customer (typically 10k-50k)
• Uses paid apps (at least 2-3, not just free ones)
• Has tracking pixels installed (Meta, TikTok, or Google)
• At least 2 decision-maker contacts available
• Clear pain point or gap you can solve
• Not already using a direct competitor to your service

Service-Specific Criteria

For Email/SMS Agencies:

• Traffic 10k+ (enough list-building potential)
• Currently using Mailchimp, no email app, or outdated platform
• Has Meta Pixel (indicates paid traffic to nurture)
• Multiple products (email flows opportunity)
• CMO or Marketing contact available

For Development Agencies:

• Traffic 20k+ (budget for dev work)
• Using free or outdated theme
• Premium apps installed (shows willingness to invest)
• Founder or CTO contact available
• Active social presence (cares about brand)

For Paid Ads Agencies:

• Already running ads (proven budget)
• No Triple Whale or attribution tool (opportunity)
• 10k-100k traffic tier
• Multiple products or collections
• CMO or Growth contact available

Red Flags: When to Skip a Lead

Not every Shopify store is worth your time. Here's when to pass:

The "fast no" rule:

If a store fails 2+ red flags, skip it immediately. Don't waste time on maybes when there are clear yeses waiting.

Sample Prospecting Workflow

Here's how to put qualification into practice:

Step 1: Build Your Initial List (30 minutes)

Start with stores that match your basic criteria:

• Use StoreInspect to filter by:
  • Niche/category (fashion, beauty, supplements, etc.)
  • Traffic tier (10k-50k)
  • Tech stack (has or missing specific apps)
• Export 100-200 stores as your starting list

Step 2: Apply STAMP Scoring (1-2 hours)

For each store, check:

1. Size - Verify traffic tier
2. Tech - Review installed apps
3. Activity - Check for pixels and ads
4. Multiple contacts - Count available decision-makers
5. Pain - Identify the gap you solve

Score each store 0-100. A good lead database has all this data pre-collected, saving hours of manual research.

Step 3: Prioritize by Score (15 minutes)

Sort your list by STAMP score:

• Hot (71-100): 20-30 stores → High-effort personalized outreach
• Warm (41-70): 40-50 stores → Standard personalized outreach
• Cold (0-40): Remove or save for later

Step 4: Get Verified Contacts (30 minutes)

For your Hot and Warm lists:

• Export contacts from StoreInspect (2-5 contacts per store)
• Verify emails are deliverable (70%+ verification rate target)
• Match contacts to your service (CMO for marketing, CTO for dev)

Need help finding contacts? See our guide on how to get Shopify store owner emails.

Step 5: Personalize and Send

Now - and only now - write your outreach. Because you've qualified properly, you can personalize:

"I noticed you're running Meta ads to 30k monthly visitors but still using Mailchimp. Most stores at your stage see 20-30% revenue lift after migrating to Klaviyo flows..."

That's not a template. That's a conversation. And qualified leads reply to conversations.

Here's another example for a development agency:

"I saw you're running Klaviyo and Triple Whale - clearly you invest in serious tools. But your site is still on Dawn with minimal customization. Most stores at your traffic level (looks like 40k+/month) see 15-25% conversion lifts from a custom theme build. Worth a quick chat?"

Research shows personalized outreach converts 26% better than generic emails. Qualification makes personalization possible.

How STAMP Compares to Traditional Frameworks

You may know BANT (Budget, Authority, Need, Timing) or CHAMP (Challenges, Authority, Money, Prioritization). These are solid frameworks, but they're designed for discovery calls - not cold prospecting.

The difference:

Use them together: STAMP filters your list before outreach. BANT or CHAMP qualifies further during actual conversations.

FAQ

How many leads should I qualify per day?

50-100 stores per hour if you're using a lead database with pre-collected data. If you're doing manual research, expect 10-20 per hour. Most agencies qualify 200-500 stores per week to maintain a healthy pipeline.

What's a good qualification rate?

20-30% of stores should pass. If 80% of stores pass your qualification, your criteria are too loose. If only 5% pass, you're too restrictive. Aim for passing 1 in 4 or 1 in 5 stores.

Should I track qualification in my CRM?

Yes. Add STAMP score as a custom field. This lets you:

• Prioritize follow-ups by score
• Track which score ranges convert best
• Refine your ideal customer profile over time

How often should I re-qualify leads?

Every 3-6 months for warm leads. Stores change. They grow. They install new apps. A store that was "cold" 6 months ago might be "hot" today. Re-check traffic, tech stack, and activity signals periodically.

What if I can't find contact information?

Move on. Stores without accessible decision-makers aren't worth the effort. Your time is better spent on qualified leads with verified contacts already available.

Should I qualify before or after finding emails?

Before. There's no point finding emails for stores that don't fit. Qualify first, then invest time in contact research only for stores that pass. This is why databases with built-in contacts are efficient - you get qualified stores AND contacts in one export.

Summary

Qualification isn't extra work. It's the work that makes everything else work.

The 5 signals of a qualified Shopify lead:

1. Size - Right traffic tier (10k-50k is the sweet spot)
2. Tech - Sophisticated stack (premium apps, not just free tools)
3. Activity - Active marketing investment (pixels, ads, social)
4. Multiple contacts - 2-3 decision-makers available
5. Pain - Clear gap you can solve

Use the STAMP framework to score leads 0-100, then focus your outreach on Hot (71+) and Warm (41-70) prospects.

Skip the red flags: Stores under 5k traffic, no contacts, already using competitors, or showing dropshipping signals.

The math is simple: 50 qualified leads beat 500 random ones. Every time.

---

Start Finding Qualified Leads Today

You now have the STAMP framework, service-specific checklists, and red flags to avoid. The only thing left is applying it.

Two ways to start:

1. Free option: Install the Store Inspector extension and manually check stores one by one. Good for validating a handful of prospects.

2. Scale option: Use StoreInspect to filter thousands of stores by traffic tier, apps, and tech stack - then export with 2-5 verified contacts per store. Better when you need 50+ qualified leads per week.

Browse Stores by Category → | Get the Free Extension →

---

Related guides:

• How to Find Shopify Stores [9 Methods] - Discovery comes before qualification
• How to Get Shopify Store Owner Emails - Getting contacts for qualified leads
• Browse Top Shopify Stores by Category - Start with pre-filtered lists